Best Italian Sub in the San Fernando Valley: A Chef Ranks 4 Classic Delis

The best Italian sub in the San Fernando Valley comes down to four old-school delis: Cavaretta's in Canoga Park, Dan's Super Subs and Cricca's in Woodland Hills, and Italia Deli in Agoura Hills. I've been eating these subs for nearly 30 years, and as of mid-November 2026, three of the four post current hours on their own websites. Cricca's is the one to call ahead. My full ranking, with the verdict on each one, is in the video below.
I'm not going to spoil the order here. Watch it, then argue with me in the comments. Below is what each deli is known for, where it is, and what I checked about its status this month.
How a chef judges an Italian sub
In the video I score every sandwich on four things: bread, meat, flavor and cross-section. Cross-section is the one people skip. Cut the sub in half and look at it. You want layers, not a pile of meat sliding out one end.
Bread matters most to me. A great roll has a crust that crackles and a soft middle that soaks up oil and vinegar without falling apart. Meat should be sliced thin and folded, not slapped down flat. And the dressing should taste like someone seasoned it on purpose.
That's the same standard I learned on the line. If one component is off, the whole plate is off.
The four delis, and where they stand now
Cavaretta's Italian Deli, Canoga Park
Address: 22045 Sherman Way, Canoga Park, at Topanga Canyon. Status: open. The deli's own site says it is open every day, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
According to Cavaretta's website, Lou Cavaretta opened the shop in 1959, and it has had the same ownership since 1983. The site also says it uses Boar's Head meats and cheeses.
The order people talk about is the Famous Italian Combo. The Infatuation describes it as mortadella, salami, capicola and provolone with all the fixings, and also points to the house-made meatball sub and the cannoli. I have a separate video on that cannoli, because it deserved one.
Dan's Super Subs, Woodland Hills
Address: 22446 Ventura Blvd, Woodland Hills. Status: open. Dan's website lists Monday to Saturday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., closed Sundays.
Dan's calls itself the "Home of the LA Street Pastrami" and says it has served the neighborhood for over 40 years. The Italian on the menu is the Mamma Mia.
A 2017 write-up from Food GPS lists capicola, mortadella, cotto salami, dry salami, bologna and provolone, plus a long run of toppings and grated Parmesan, on a sesame seed roll. That sesame roll is the whole personality of a Dan's sub. Some people love it. Some people think it's too soft.
Cricca's Italian Deli and Subs, Woodland Hills
Address: 4876 Topanga Canyon Blvd, Woodland Hills. Status: I could not find a 2026 posting from the deli itself. The most recent profile I could open, a 2023 KFI AM 640 small business feature, listed daily hours of 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. My own video shows it operating in May 2026. Call before you drive over.
That KFI piece says Cricca's has been at this spot since 1969, and owners Kevin and Marla McHenry kept the original 1969 recipes when they took over. Atly's listing notes the sandwiches come on Dutch Crunch bread and that dine-in space is tight, so takeout is easier.
Fun local history: in 2015 the Calabasas High Courier, my old school paper, ran a Cricca's vs. Dan's debate. The Cricca's writer called the bread the most important part of the sandwich. The Dan's writer called it overcooked. The rivalry is real.
Italia Deli and Bakery, Agoura Hills
Address: 5657 Kanan Rd, Agoura Hills. Status: open. Italia Deli's website lists Monday to Friday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m., Saturday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sunday 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.
The site says it has been family owned since 1981 and bakes its Italian rolls and bread from scratch every day. That's a big deal. When the bakery and the deli are the same room, you can taste it.
The Italian Cold Cuts sub is mortadella, cotto salame, Molinari salame and provolone, listed at $14.99 to $23.99 by size. A lot of you asked about the porchetta. Food GPS described it in 2015 as slow-roasted, spiced pork with fennel, onion and celery on a house-baked roll. The current menu page I checked doesn't mention porchetta or cannoli, so ask at the counter.
Before you go: a few tips from the counter
- Go early. All four close by early evening, and Dan's is closed Sundays.
- Pick your roll. At Italia you can choose a hard or soft roll. Hard holds up better if you're driving it somewhere.
- Eat it within the hour. Oil and vinegar keep working on the bread. Twenty minutes is perfect. Two hours is a sponge.
- Save room. The Infatuation calls out Cavaretta's cannoli, and I gave it its own video. My verdict is in there.
If you end up doing all four like I did, you'll cover a lot of the West Valley and the Conejo Valley in one afternoon. That's a pretty good way to see the area, by the way. My Woodland Hills neighborhood guide and Agoura Hills guide cover what's around each stop.
What homes near these delis sell for
Two of these four delis sit in Woodland Hills, and Italia Deli anchors a corner of Agoura Hills. If you live near any of them, here's the baseline for what a single-family home has been selling for.
- Woodland Hills 91364: median sale price $1.36 million, about 26 days on market.
- Woodland Hills 91367: median sale price $1.33 million, about 23 days on market.
- Agoura Hills 91301: median sale price $1.53 million, about 44 days on market.
Source: The MLS, single-family homes sold in the 12 months ending October 7, 2026.
Near Cavaretta's in Canoga Park? I don't have a ZIP median for that one here, but I can pull the recent sales on your street.
Or call or text me at 818-297-8667. I'll pull the sales that actually compare to yours.